Servo motor repair vs replacement: how to decide
A failed servo motor can stop a whole machine. This guide explains how to diagnose the fault and decide between repair, an identical replacement or an alternative.
Many plants still run machines controlled by Siemens S5. Here is how to keep them running while you plan a controlled migration instead of an emergency one.
Many production lines still depend on programmable logic controllers that left the manufacturer's catalog long ago. The Siemens SIMATIC S5 family is the best known example: it has been discontinued for many years, and Siemens positions the SIMATIC S7 range as its successor. Yet S5 controllers still run presses, conveyors and process plants worldwide. This article explains how to manage that risk and migrate on your own schedule.
Discontinuation usually happens in phases: new sales stop first, then spare modules and official repair services are reduced and finally end. The controller still works, but every failure becomes harder to fix.
For the plant, the practical consequences are:
None of this means the machine must be replaced tomorrow, but the risk has to be managed actively.
Start with a complete list of every S5 system in the plant. For each controller, record:
The order numbers are the most important part. Siemens order numbers include version information, and replacement modules must often match closely to be accepted by the CPU and the program. Our guide on how to read a machine nameplate explains what to record from labels.
A failed CPU or lost memory module is far more serious without a current program backup. Make sure that:
Tip: Test your backup by loading it into a spare CPU on the bench, if you have one. A backup that has never been restored is only a hope.
For critical S5 systems, waiting for a failure and then searching for a module is the most expensive option. Typical spares options are:
| Option | Advantages | Things to check |
|---|---|---|
| New old stock (unused original modules) | Original condition, no wear | Storage conditions, age of capacitors and batteries |
| Refurbished or tested used modules | Often easier to find | Who tested it, how, and what warranty applies |
| Repair of your own failed modules | Keeps the exact version you use | Availability of a capable repair service and turnaround |
| Spares taken from decommissioned machines | Matches your installed base | Unknown history, needs testing |
A common approach is to keep a spare CPU, power supply and 1 of each I/O module type used in critical lines, and to test spares periodically.
Because S5 parts are no longer supplied through the manufacturer's normal channels, they have to be found through distributors, surplus dealers and specialists. A sourcing agency such as LiteHard can search this market on your behalf and check the exact order number and version before a quote is made. When buying used modules, follow the precautions in our article on counterfeit industrial parts.
Keeping spares buys time, but it does not remove the obsolescence problem. Sooner or later the controller should be migrated. Common migration paths are:
The S5 hardware is removed and replaced by a current controller, such as a Siemens S7 system. The program is converted or rewritten, and the wiring is moved to new I/O modules. This gives the cleanest result but needs the longest shutdown.
The CPU is replaced first while the existing I/O is kept for a period, using interface solutions available on the market, or the plant migrates line by line. This spreads the cost and the risk, and allows each stage to be tested before the next one.
Siemens has provided conversion tools for translating STEP 5 programs into S7 format. Converted code usually still needs manual review and testing, especially for timing, special function blocks and communication.
For complex machines, the machine builder or an integrator may offer a complete control retrofit, including drives and panels.
Whichever path you choose, keep the old system and its spares until the new one has proven itself in production.
The market for legacy modules changes over time, and the number of engineers familiar with STEP 5 keeps shrinking. Review your inventory, backups and spare stock at least once a year, and adjust the migration timeline if failures become more frequent. A structured critical spares plan helps to set priorities across all legacy systems, not only PLCs.
Send us what you know about it: part number, machine nameplate, photos or a drawing. We search manufacturers, distributors and stock holders worldwide and send you a quote when we find it.
Request a partA failed servo motor can stop a whole machine. This guide explains how to diagnose the fault and decide between repair, an identical replacement or an alternative.
A bearing designation tells you the type, size and design details. Learn how to read it, decode common suffixes and measure a bearing with no marking.
The spindle is the heart of a CNC machine. Learn which spindle parts wear out, how failures show up and how to identify replacement parts correctly.